What was already known
The authors proposed Conjecture 5 as one step in a differential-equation approach to the broader Courtade–Kumar problem.
AI involvement
Chen, Gohari and Nair credit Adel Javanmard, Honghao Lin, Vahab Mirrokni and David Woodruff with finding the parameter choices using a Gemini-based agentic system. Fan Zhou later supplied a separate counterexample.
- Appendix B, discovery credit and separate exampleAppendix B, discovery credit and separate example
Importance
The examples rule out the auxiliary inequality as stated and identify where that route needed a different bound.
Technical verification
The revised paper gives the explicit parameter values and reports direct numerical evaluations. Rigorous error intervals for these two gap values are undocumented.
- Numerical gaps in Appendix BNumerical gaps in Appendix B
Human understanding
The authors locate the failures near the boundary and explain their role in the proof program. A human derivation of why the displayed points violate the inequality is undocumented.
Other useful sources
Correction and publication history
Reviewed the primary result and its documented AI and checking scope.
Read this published revision