Annular webs and Guralnick’s conjecture

Get email updates

Tom Goertzen, Abel Lacabanne, Daniel Tubbenhauer, Pedro Vaz

For every integer m≥2m\geq 2 and all sufficiently large primes pp depending on mm, the authors construct a faithful absolutely irreducible module for the finite simple group PSL2m+1(Fp)\mathrm{PSL}_{2m+1}(\mathbb F_p) over F‾p\overline{\mathbb F}_p whose first cohomology has dimension at least ⌈(m+1)/2⌉\lceil(m+1)/2\rceil.

What was already known

Earlier examples produced large dimensions. Earlier affine Kazhdan–Lusztig constructions showed unbounded extension dimensions between simple modules, where the source module need not be trivial.

AI involvement AI-centered

The authors proposed putting their earlier web diagrams on an annulus and supplied an initial picture. They credit GPT Astra 6.0 with finding the working family and calculation. They used that argument as a blueprint for the paper.

Importance Major

The family disproves a longstanding uniform bound in finite-group representation theory. The same annular graph works at every rank in the family by changing its edge thicknesses.

Technical verification Partial

The authors report Lean checks of the annular family, the web calculation, the row sum and the deduction of the cohomology bound from named hypotheses. The formal deduction assumes results from representation theory, including the link from the coefficients to first cohomology.

Formal checking

The authors report Lean checks of the annular family, the web calculation, the row sum and the deduction of the cohomology bound from named hypotheses. The formal deduction assumes results from representation theory, including the link from the coefficients to first cohomology.

Checker
Goertzen, Lacabanne, Tubbenhauer and Vaz, reporting the Lean development
Scope
For every integer m≥2m\geq 2 and all sufficiently large primes pp depending on mm, the authors construct a faithful absolutely irreducible module for the finite simple group PSL2m+1(Fp)\mathrm{PSL}_{2m+1}(\mathbb F_p) over F‾p\overline{\mathbb F}_p whose first cohomology has dimension at least ⌈(m+1)/2⌉\lceil(m+1)/2\rceil.
Basis
Reported by the linked checker

Human understanding Explained

The authors explain how a single annular diagram produces a row of coefficients whose sum grows quadratically in the parameter. At least one coefficient then grows linearly, and the authors relate it to first cohomology in sufficiently large characteristic.

Correction and publication history