Equal circles in a circle: optimal radii for 15, 16, 17, 18, and 20 circles

Get email updates

nor

Nor reports the exact least container radius for 15, 16, 17, 18 and 20 unit disks with disjoint interiors. For 15, 16 and 17 disks the optimal layout is unique up to rigid motion and relabeling. For 20 disks, every optimal layout has a fixed arrangement of 19 disks, with the remaining disk free to move within a specified region.

What was already known

The layouts were already known as candidates. Earlier proofs established the optimum for up to 14 disks and for 19 disks.

AI involvement AI-led

Nor credits GPT-6 Astra with finding the proofs. Nor chose the cases, guided the search, repaired issues, rewrote the exposition and checked the arguments. Claude Opus 5.5 helped recheck the work and write the accompanying account.

Importance Notable

The five proofs would complete the optimal radii for all disk counts up to 20.

Technical verification Formal (exact rational computation + human)

Nor reports checking the full argument by hand. The supplied programs use exact rational arithmetic to rule out ranges of disk positions and certify the bounds used in the rigidity arguments.

Formal checking

Exact rational checks of the finite case subdivisions, angle bounds and rigidity constants.

Checker
nor’s verification programs
Scope
Finite computational steps for 15, 16, 17, 18 and 20 disks
Basis
Reported by the linked checker

Human understanding Explained

Nor explains how moving disks outward reduces the cases, how the computation narrows the possible layouts, and how the final rigidity argument determines their exact positions.

Correction and publication history