No regular icosahedron has a rational point on every face: a proof checked in Lean

Get email updates

Mikhail Levit

No regular icosahedron in R3\mathbb{R}^{3} has a point with rational coordinates on each of its 20 closed faces, for any position, positive scale or orientation, including reflections.

What was already known

Ilya Bogdanov posed the question in 2023. Jeremy Rouse gave a configuration illustrating why the extended face planes cannot replace the triangular faces in an impossibility proof.

AI involvement AI-led

Levit credits OpenAI Codex with the reduction and decomposition. Anthropic Claude developed the Lean formalization and its exact certificates. Levit posed the problem and directed the work.

Importance Notable

This answers Bogdanov’s question and handles the face boundaries through exact inequalities on the rotation parameters.

Technical verification Formal (Lean 4)

Levit reports that the Lean kernel checked the complete theorem and all 48 certificates. The axiom audit lists only Lean’s standard axioms.

Formal checking

Levit reports that the Lean kernel checked the complete theorem and all 48 certificates. The axiom audit lists only Lean’s standard axioms.

Checker
Lean kernel as reported by Mikhail Levit
Scope
No regular icosahedron in R3\mathbb{R}^{3} has a point with rational coordinates on each of its 20 closed faces, for any position, positive scale or orientation, including reflections.
Basis
Reported by the linked checker

Human understanding Few

Levit directed the work and reports checking the results. The paper credits the models with the mathematical argument and drafting, and identifies no separately written human explanation of the central reduction.

Correction and publication history