Rational points on the faces of a regular icosahedron
Can a regular icosahedron in three-dimensional space have a point with rational coordinates on every face? A point on an edge or vertex counts for each closed face that contains it. The icosahedron can be placed, scaled and oriented arbitrarily.
Why it matters and what counts as progress
Why it matters: This question asks how the arithmetic of rational coordinates interacts with the geometry of a regular solid. The boundaries of the faces matter because the extended planes can contain rational points even when the triangular faces do not.
What counts as progress: A construction must place a rational point on each of the 20 triangular faces. An impossibility proof must handle every positive scale, translation and orientation, including reflections.
How the problem developed
- 16 Aug 2023 · Question [3]
Ilya Bogdanov Asked whether a regular icosahedron can have a rational point on each face. Jeremy Rouse discussed a near example involving the planes through the faces.
Mikhail Levit with OpenAI Codex and Anthropic Claude Reported that no placement, scale or orientation in three dimensions works. The Lean proof checks an exact case analysis.
AI contribution
No regular icosahedron has a rational point on every face: a proof checked in Lean
No regular icosahedron in has a point with rational coordinates on each of its 20 closed faces, for any position, positive scale or orientation, including reflections.
Sources
Publication history
No regular icosahedron has a rational point on every face: a proof checked in Lean
Daily emails by default, only when there’s an update.