OEIS A060841: the exact integrality set for the reciprocal lcm determinant

For positive integers n, the reciprocal of the determinant of the matrix with entries 1/lcm⁡(i,j)1/\operatorname{lcm}(i,j) is an integer exactly for n from 1 through 34 and for n equal to 36 or 38.

What was already known

R. G. Wilson v conjectured this list in OEIS A060841. Smith’s determinant identity gives the reciprocal as the square of n!n! divided by the product of the first n positive totients.

AI involvement AI-led

Veljjanoski credits Claude Fable 5.1 with finding the proof using Smith’s determinant and a power-of-2 obstruction. He selected the problem and directed the work.

Importance Modest

A bound on powers of 2 in the totient product rules out all large sizes. Exact checks settle the remaining finite range.

Technical verification Formal (Lean 4)

The project reports that Lean’s kernel checked the full integrality classification. An exact Python check also tested the determinant identity and the finite divisibility conditions over stated ranges.

Formal checking

The project reports that Lean’s kernel checked the full integrality classification. An exact Python check also tested the determinant identity and the finite divisibility conditions over stated ranges.

Checker
Lean kernel as reported by Daniel Veljjanoski
Scope
For positive integers n, the reciprocal of the determinant of the matrix with entries 1/lcm⁡(i,j)1/\operatorname{lcm}(i,j) is an integer exactly for n from 1 through 34 and for n equal to 36 or 38.
Basis
Reported by the linked checker

Human understanding Few

Veljjanoski checked the statement and the result. The project attributes the proof to Claude and documents no separate human explanation of the key bound.

Correction and publication history