Erdős 146 degeneracy-based extremal-number conjecture

How well can an extremal edge-count exponent be predicted from the degree and degeneracy structure of a forbidden graph? Erdős Problem 146 asks this for the specified connected bipartite two-degenerate class, with a proposed n^(3/2) scale.

Why it matters and what counts as progress

Why it matters: A larger extremal exponent would show that two-degeneracy and the stated degree conditions do not force the proposed density scale.

What counts as progress: Construct a graph in the stated degree class with extremal number at least c n^(3/2+ε), or prove a valid restricted exponent theorem.

How the problem developed

  1. 1984 · Conjecture [1]

    Paul Erdős and Miklós Simonovits The problem collection attributes the bound ex(n,H) = O(n^(2−1/r)) for bipartite r-degenerate graphs to Erdős and Simonovits.

  2. 2003 · Partial result [1]

    Noga Alon, Michael Krivelevich and Benny Sudakov Proved a weaker general exponent and the conjectured exponent under an additional maximum-degree condition on one bipartition side.

  3. 1 Aug 2026 · Counterexample [2][1]

    OpenAI internal model Reported a fixed connected bipartite 2-degenerate graph H with ex(n,H) at least c·n^(3/2+ε), disproving the universal conjecture at r = 2.

AI contribution

Sources

  1. Erdős Problem 146
  2. OpenAI, Ten Advances in Mathematics, Chapter 10
  3. OpenAI, degeneracy formalization manifest
  4. Sienicki and coauthors, Chapter 10 human review
  5. OpenAI, Ten Advances in Mathematics release and attribution
Website timeline

Publication dates and editorial changes.