Second-order asymptotics in the corrected Erdős Problem 796

Let g₃(n) be the largest size of A⊂{1,…,n} such that each integer m has fewer than three representations m=a₁a₂ with distinct a₁<a₂ in A. Beyond g₃(n)∼n log log n/log n, does the residual divided by n/log n converge to a constant? This uses the corrected log n scale, not the printed log-squared scale.

Why it matters and what counts as progress

Why it matters: The second-order coefficient refines a classical multiplicative-representation extremal asymptotic; the corrected scale is essential to the question.

What counts as progress: Prove convergence of the corrected second-order residual, determine its constant or improve matching error bounds.

How the problem developed

  1. 1964 · Partial result [1]

    Paul Erdős Established the leading asymptotic g₃(n)∼n log log n/log n for the largest subset A of {1,…,n} in which each integer has fewer than three factorizations m=a₁a₂ with a₁<a₂ in A.

  2. 1969 · Open question [1]

    Paul Erdős Asked for a second-order term; the printed problem has a log-squared denominator, while the corrected formulation uses log n.

  3. 18 Oct 2026 · Proof claim [2]

    Star Fleet Reported convergence of the normalized second-order residual to an explicit constant written as Mertens’ constant plus a variational limit.

AI contribution

Sources

  1. Erdős Problem 796, original statements and corrected formulation
  2. Star Fleet, Erdős Problem 796 report
  3. Gajjala, separate Erdős 796 proof claim
Website timeline

Publication dates and editorial changes.