Index and nullity of Karcher saddle towers

A Karcher saddle tower is a minimal surface that repeats by translation and has an even number of ends. Identify points that differ by a whole number of periods. On the resulting surface, the Morse index counts independent directions in which a perturbation decreases area. Nullity counts independent bounded solutions of the linearised minimal-surface equation.

Why it matters and what counts as progress

Why it matters: Index and nullity describe stability and the possible deformations of these surfaces. The values also help determine how saddle towers can be used to construct other minimal surfaces.

What counts as progress: Compute the index and bounded nullity for a specified family and number of periods, explain how they depend on the geometry, or prove bounds for cases outside the known formulas.

How the problem developed

  1. 1988 · Saddle towers [4]

    Hermann Karcher Constructed singly periodic embedded minimal surfaces with an even number of ends.

  2. 25 Aug 2026 · Exact index and nullity [1]

    David Wiygul with Claude Gave formulas for the two-period and six-ended families, including the spectral threshold for the six-ended case.

  3. 9 Nov 2026 · Lean and NanoDa checks [2][3]

    David Wiygul and the KarcherIndex collaborators Documented machine checking of selected formulas for the constructed surfaces and certified bounds on the threshold.

AI contribution

Morse index of Karcher saddle towers in R2×S1(m)\mathbb{R}^{2} \times S^{1}(m)

David Wiygul

For the constructed Karcher towers with 2k2k ends and two periods, the index is 4k−34k-3 and the bounded nullity is 3 for every k≥3k\geq 3. For the six-ended tower with mm periods, the index is 6m−4⌊mα∗⌋−36m-4\lfloor m\alpha_*\rfloor-3. The bounded nullity is 7 when mα∗m\alpha_* is an integer and 3 otherwise, with one threshold α∗∈(1/3,1/2)\alpha_*\in(1/3,1/2) for all positive integers mm.

AI involvementAI-centered
ImportanceNotable
Technical verificationFormal (Lean 4 and NanoDa)
Human understandingExplained
Paper date:

Sources

  1. Wiygul’s saddle-tower index and nullity formulas
  2. KarcherIndex verification and scope
  3. Palomar checking record
  4. Karcher’s embedded minimal surfaces
Publication history