Separation of homotopy-interleaving distances

Persistence diagrams describe objects that change with a real parameter. Interleaving distances measure how much one must shift that parameter to compare two diagrams. When do distances based on homology, derived diagrams and homotopy agree, and when can they differ?

Why it matters and what counts as progress

Why it matters: Homology records only part of a chain complex. A strict gap shows that some features of a diagram disappear when the comparison uses homology alone.

What counts as progress: Prove equality under stated hypotheses or construct a diagram with a strict gap. Specify the coefficient ring and which diagram replacements each distance allows.

How the problem developed

  1. 2025 · Distances agree in a field setting [1]

    Katsuhiko Kuribayashi, Takahito Naito, Shun Wakatsuki and Toshihiro Yamaguchi Kuribayashi, Naito, Wakatsuki and Yamaguchi proved equality for the corresponding algebraic interleaving distances under their field-coefficient hypotheses.

  2. 3 Nov 2026 · A group-algebra example [2]

    Fairfax-Ball project with AI assistance An AI-developed five-stage diagram has different homology, derived-diagram and strict homotopy-interleaving distances.

AI contribution

A quantitative homotopy-interleaving gap over the cyclic-four group algebra

For an explicit five-stage real-indexed persistence diagram F of chain complexes over the group algebra of C4C_{4} over the field of two elements, the homology interleaving distance to zero is 1/2 and the derived-diagram distance is 1. The strict homotopy-interleaving distance is at least 5/4 and at most 5/2, allowing whole-diagram zigzags in both inputs.

AI involvementAI-led
ImportanceNotable
Technical verificationFormal (Lean)
Human understandingFew
Paper date:

Sources

  1. Kuribayashi, Naito, Wakatsuki and Yamaguchi on algebraic interleavings
  2. A quantitative homotopy-interleaving gap over the cyclic-four group algebra
  3. Pinned theorem, provenance and checking record
Publication history