Pointwise convergence of bilinear averages for two commuting transformations

For commuting measure-preserving maps T,S of a probability space, do N⁻¹∑ₙ₌₀ᴺ⁻¹ f(Tⁿx)g(Sⁿx) converge almost everywhere when f∈Lᵖ, g∈Lᑫ and 1/p+1/q≤1? No mixing or invertibility is assumed.

Why it matters and what counts as progress

Why it matters: Pointwise convergence is stronger than norm convergence and goes beyond known distal or single-transformation settings.

What counts as progress: An almost-everywhere theorem for the full exponent and map range, or a valid counterexample, without adding stronger dynamical assumptions.

How the problem developed

  1. 2018 · Partial result [1]

    Sebastián Donoso and Wenbo Sun Proved pointwise convergence for commuting transformations in distal systems, a restricted setting for bilinear averages.

  2. 18 Oct 2026 · Formalized result [2][3]

    Floris van Doorn, Polona Durcik, Lenka Slavíková, Joris Roos and Christoph Thiele Reported almost-everywhere convergence for two commuting measure-preserving maps and f∈Lᵖ, g∈Lᑫ when 1/p+1/q≤1, without mixing or invertibility assumptions.

AI contribution

Sources

  1. Donoso and Sun, Pointwise multiple averages for systems with two commuting transformations
  2. Project theorem and AI/human roles
  3. Human-authored formal theorem
  4. Exact protected comparison statement
  5. Palomar: pinned kernel-checking record
  6. Guo, Xiao and Zhang: separate proof and prior history
Website timeline

Publication dates and editorial changes.