Morse index of Karcher saddle towers in R2×S1(m)\mathbb{R}^{2} \times S^{1}(m)

David Wiygul

For the constructed Karcher towers with 2k2k ends and two periods, the index is 4k−34k-3 and the bounded nullity is 3 for every k≥3k\geq 3. For the six-ended tower with mm periods, the index is 6m−4⌊mα∗⌋−36m-4\lfloor m\alpha_*\rfloor-3. The bounded nullity is 7 when mα∗m\alpha_* is an integer and 3 otherwise, with one threshold α∗∈(1/3,1/2)\alpha_*\in(1/3,1/2) for all positive integers mm.

What was already known

Karcher constructed the saddle-tower family. Wiygul reduced the index and nullity questions for the two-period and six-ended families to spectral problems on simpler regions.

AI involvement AI-centered

Wiygul supplied the geometric reductions and Fourier approach. He credits Claude Fable 5 and Claude Opus 4.8 with key analytic computations and ideas, including the arguments in Proposition 4.56 and Lemma 4.64 that he identifies as essential to the six-ended result.

Importance Notable

The formulas give the exact index and bounded nullity in two infinite families of periodic quotients. The six-ended case ties changes in nullity to a single spectral threshold.

Technical verification Formal (Lean 4 and NanoDa)

Wiygul reports statement comparison and acceptance by Lean and NanoDa for the five selected declarations, including both index and nullity formulas and the certified bounds on the threshold.

Possible mismatch: The KarcherIndex documentation says that Theorem 1.1(v) in the preprint should include the endpoint r=0r=0 in its checkerboard containment statement. The checked index and nullity claims use the constructed realizations.

Formal checking

Wiygul reports statement comparison and acceptance by Lean and NanoDa for the five selected declarations, including both index and nullity formulas and the certified bounds on the threshold.

Checker
Lean 4 and NanoDa, reported by the KarcherIndex project
Scope
For the constructed Karcher towers with 2k2k ends and two periods, the index is 4k−34k-3 and the bounded nullity is 3 for every k≥3k\geq 3. For the six-ended tower with mm periods, the index is 6m−4⌊mα∗⌋−36m-4\lfloor m\alpha_*\rfloor-3. The bounded nullity is 7 when mα∗m\alpha_* is an integer and 3 otherwise, with one threshold α∗∈(1/3,1/2)\alpha_*\in(1/3,1/2) for all positive integers mm.
Basis
Reported by the linked checker

Human understanding Explained

Wiygul explains how symmetry and the Dirichlet-to-Neumann map reduce the index and nullity calculations to Fourier analysis on the circle. He describes which spectral modes contribute at each phase.

Correction and publication history