Width bounds for Betti counts of four-generated numerical semigroups

For a minimally four-generated numerical semigroup S=⟨n₀<n₁<n₂<n₃⟩, can its toric ideal always be generated by at most 2W elements, where W=(n₃−n₀)/gcd(n₁−n₀,n₂−n₀,n₃−n₀)? The target is over every field.

Why it matters and what counts as progress

Why it matters: A linear normalized-width bound improves quadratic relation-count estimates for every minimally four-generated numerical semigroup.

What counts as progress: Replace quadratic generator-count bounds by a uniform linear width bound or determine sharp extremal families.

How the problem developed

  1. 26 Jul 2024 · Related result [2]

    Giulio Caviglia, Alessio Moscariello and Alessio Sammartano Proved the Herzog–Stamate width bound for four-generated numerical semigroups except at finitely many widths; their theorem covers all widths at least 40.

  2. 6 Oct 2026 · AI-assisted theorem and formalization [1][2][3]

    Ben Keene, GPT-6 Astra and Claude agents Reported a linear bound of at most 2W for the first Betti count of every minimally four-generated numerical semigroup, where W is the normalized width; Lean proves the upper-bound statements.

AI contribution

AI-led proof gives a linear Betti bound for four-generated semigroups

For a minimally four-generated numerical semigroup S=⟨n₀<n₁<n₂<n₃⟩, the minimal number of generators of its toric ideal is at most 2W over any field, where W=(n₃−n₀)/gcd(n₁−n₀,n₂−n₀,n₃−n₀). Consequently it is at most twice the ordinary width n₃−n₀.

AI involvementAI-led
ImportanceNotable
Human understandingFew
Reported

Sources

  1. Herzog and Stamate, On the defining equations of the tangent cone of a numerical semigroup ring
  2. Earlier four-generator width result
  3. Keene, Linear upper bounds for the first Betti number of four-generated numerical semigroups: formalization and provenance
  4. Keene’s semigroup formalization
  5. Semigroup theorem correspondence and build record
Website timeline

Publication dates and editorial changes.